The Legal Signals: Who Is Who
Legal disputes are among the oldest uses of Qimen Dunjia. The classical system assigns a specific symbol to every party in a lawsuit (plaintiff, defendant, judge, lawyer, evidence), so a single chart can map the entire power structure of a case. Learn these nine symbols and you can follow any legal reading:
| Symbol | What it stands for in a legal chart |
|---|---|
| 值符Chief Star | The plaintiff: the party who initiates the legal action. |
| 天乙Ground-plate star under Chief Star | The defendant: the party being sued. Specifically, the star sitting on the ground plate beneath the Chief Star. |
| 开门Open Door | The judge: the authority who decides the case. |
| 六合Partner | Witnesses and evidence: the supporting material that can sway the verdict. |
| 景门Scenery Door | The lawsuit filing or complaint: the formal document that starts the case. |
| 丁奇Ding Qi | The court summons: the official notice that compels appearance. |
| 惊门Dispute Door | The lawyer: legal counsel representing either side. |
| 甲午辛Jia-Wu-Xin | The criminal or guilty party, in cases involving criminal liability. |
| 壬 / 癸Ren / Gui | Prison (壬, "heavenly jail") and the net (癸, "earthly net"): confinement and inescapability. |
The grammar of a legal reading is adversarial: who controls whom, and whose side does the judge lean toward? Unlike career or relationship charts, a lawsuit chart is explicitly a contest: two parties measured against each other, with a third party (the judge) holding the scale.
How Legal Charts Are Judged
Classical Qimen judges legal disputes through four layers. Once you understand this sequence, the scenarios below are just specific applications of the same framework:
Layer 1: Plaintiff vs. defendant strength. Compare the Chief Star (plaintiff) palace and the Tian Yi (defendant) palace. Whichever side is thriving in the current season, carries auspicious stars and formations, and controls the other's element, holds the advantage. If the plaintiff's palace controls the defendant's, the plaintiff wins. If the defendant's palace controls the plaintiff's, the defendant wins.
Layer 2: The judge's inclination. The Open Door represents the judge or the court. Its relationship to both parties reveals the judge's stance:
Open Door controls both parties: an impartial, strict judge who rules by the book.
Open Door generates the plaintiff (Chief Star): the judge leans toward the plaintiff.
Open Door generates the defendant (Tian Yi): the judge leans toward the defendant.
Open Door entombed (Entombment): a confused judge who cannot see the case clearly.
Open Door void: the case will not be accepted or heard at all.
Open Door in reversal (Reversed Yin): the current judge is wrong for this case; seek a change of venue or judge.
Layer 3: Filing and evidence. The Scenery Door represents the formal complaint or filing. If Scenery Door is thriving, carries the three treasures (Three Wonders), and is not controlled by Open Door, the case will be accepted. If Open Door controls Scenery Door, the filing is rejected. Critical warning: if Scenery Door sits void with Black Tortoise or Serpent, the complaint itself contains false or fabricated claims. Meanwhile, Partner represents the evidence. If Partner is void, the evidence is insufficient, no matter how strong the case looks on paper.
Layer 4: Criminal sentencing. In criminal cases, Jiawu-Xin represents the accused. If Jiawu-Xin carries 壬 (heavenly jail) or 癸 (earthly net), imprisonment is virtually certain. But if Jiawu-Xin carries any of the three treasures (especially Ding, Ding), there is a path to release or acquittal. The final verdict also depends on the relationship between Jiawu-Xin and Open Door (the judge).
Scenario: Will I Win This Case?
The most common legal question. The chart is read as a head-to-head contest between plaintiff and defendant, with the judge as the deciding factor.
- Your side (Chief Star or Tian Yi) thriving in season with auspicious formations
- Your palace element controls the opponent's palace element
- Open Door (judge) generates your palace, the court leans your way
- Partner strong and present, solid evidence supporting your position
- Opponent's palace controls yours and carries auspicious stars
- Open Door generates the opponent, the judge favors the other side
- Partner void, your evidence is insufficient or missing
- Open Door entombed or void, the judge is confused or the case stalls
Scenario: Will the Court Accept My Case?
Before winning or losing, there is a prior question: will the court even hear the case? This is where the Scenery Door, the complaint, takes center stage.
- Scenery Door thriving in season with Three Wonders (three treasures), a strong, well-drafted filing
- Scenery Door not controlled by Open Door, the judge sees no reason to reject
- Partner present and strong, sufficient evidence accompanies the filing
- Auspicious formations in the Scenery Door palace, favorable procedural conditions
- Open Door controls Scenery Door, the court rejects the filing
- Scenery Door void with Black Tortoise or Serpent, the complaint contains false claims
- Partner void, insufficient evidence to support the case
- Scenery Door weak or dead in season, the filing lacks legal standing
Settlement or Fight?
Not every dispute ends in a courtroom verdict. The classical system identifies specific patterns that point toward settlement, mediation, or voluntary withdrawal, and knowing these can save both time and legal fees.
When the plaintiff (Chief Star) and defendant (Tian Yi) are equal in strength, both thriving or both weak, with neither controlling the other. The classical term is same-element, mutual balance. This almost always points to a settlement or mediation rather than a decisive verdict. Neither side has the leverage to crush the other, so the rational move is to negotiate.
There are also directional patterns. If the plaintiff's palace generates the defendant's palace, the plaintiff is the one who will seek settlement voluntarily; they are, energetically, already giving ground. Conversely, if the defendant's palace generates the plaintiff's, the defendant is the one who will initiate settlement talks. These generation patterns do not mean weakness. They mean one side recognizes that fighting costs more than conceding.
Push to trial when your side clearly controls the opponent, the judge (Open Door) generates you, and your evidence (Partner) is solid.
Settle when forces are balanced (same-element), when your side is generating the opponent (you are already giving ground), or when the judge is entombed or void. A confused or absent judge benefits no one.
"A legal chart maps the balance of power between parties.
it cannot replace counsel from a qualified attorney."
Qimen Dunjia readings are a traditional metaphysical framework, not legal advice. They do not constitute professional counsel, cannot predict court outcomes with certainty, and should never be used as a substitute for consultation with a licensed attorney. Always seek qualified legal representation for any real legal matter.
Facing a legal question right now? Ask it as your first free reading. QimenIt reads the legal palaces above and explains each flag it finds, in plain language.
Cast a Free Chart →